26th June 2017
Gary Bubb, Ruberto Israel & Weiner
To remain competitive in the business world, companies must hire, retain and incentivize productive employees. For some time now employers have been turning to “equity” compensation – stock options, restricted stock, etc. – to meet these needs. However, if the employer is a limited liability company that is taxed as a partnership (an “LLC,” and almost all limited liability companies with more than one member are taxed as partnerships), granting equity compensation to employees creates tax problems that don’t arise for corporate employees. MSI's Massachusetts law member Ruberto Israel & Weiner explains further.
If the employer is a corporation and grants stock to a W-2 employee, the employer will continue to treat the employee as a W-2 employee after the grant. The employer will continue to withhold income and employment taxes from the employee’s pay; the “employment tax” situation following the stock grant is unchanged.
However, if the employer is an LLC and grants an ownership interest to a W-2 employee, the tax situation changes dramatically. The employer cannot continue to treat the new member as an employee for employment tax purposes. The former W-2 employee is now a “partner” (the “New Partner”), and is subject to an entirely new tax regime that is bewildering for the uninitiated. The New Partner is now:
Many times, the employer LLC issues the equity compensation and continues to W-2 the New Partner as if nothing had happened, blissfully unaware of the employee’s status change and the new requirements. By the time the employer’s accountants figure out what happened, a lot of water has flowed under the bridge. This triggers additional problems:
There are no easy work-arounds if an employer LLC decides to continue to treat New Partners as employees for employment tax purposes. Some businesses use a “tiered” approach in which the employer LLC forms a subsidiary LLC or a “lower-tier partnership” that acts as the actual employer or co-employer of employees who are to receive equity compensation in the employer LLC. Since the subsidiary LLC or lower-tier partnership is the entity that issues the W-2 to employees, those employees can become members of the employer LLC and still receive a W-2 from the subsidiary LLC or lower-tier partnership. As an alternative, the employer LLC and the New Partners could set up an S-corp. that “employs” the New Partners, who will be shareholders of the S-corporation rather than members of the employer LLC. The equity compensation is then issued directly to the S-corporation, and the New Partners hopefully get the benefit of the less cumbersome employment tax treatment enjoyed by S-corporation shareholder/employees.
The solutions that are available under current law are complicated and expensive, and are difficult to explain to the New Partners for whose benefit they are being established.
Since LLCs are often the entity of choice for new businesses, better solutions need to be found that will permit LLCs to grant small doses of equity compensation to W-2 employees. Hopefully, in upcoming tax reform, Congress will enact changes that will resolve the issues discussed above and permit W-2 employees who receive equity compensation to continue to be treated as W-2 employees for employment tax purposes.
Glad you still remember #teddysbigtrip! https://t.co/6ExdvY682h
RT @haysmacPIMBs: Collaboration with our international partners @MSI_Global increasingly important for our UK clients. https://t.co/ai0FAFR…
RT @pamirlaw: The @MSI_Global announced the appointment of @nicholasvchen as one of the MSI Area Representatives. Nick will be joining regi…